Skip to content
Rebate.Blue

Carrier vs Trane: heat pump ratings compared

Against heat pumps of the same size and type, a typical Carrier model beats 47% and a typical Trane model 52%. Trane rates higher overall.

Covers older R-410A heat pumps, no longer installed new. See models sold today · Updated

Carrier

47%

of similar heat pumps beaten by its typical model

About average

701 models listed

Trane

52%

of similar heat pumps beaten by its typical model

About average

309 models listed

Rating by ratingEach bar is the share of same-size, same-type heat pumps that a typical model beats, so the two brands compare fairly even if they make different sizes.
  • Efficiency on a 5°F dayCOP at 5°FCarrier: Beats 58%Trane: Beats 69%
  • Heating power kept at 5°FCapacity at 5°F vs 47°FCarrier: Beats 32%Trane: Beats 43%
  • Winter-long heating efficiencyHSPF2Carrier: Beats 38%Trane: Beats 35%
  • Summer-long cooling efficiencySEER2Carrier: Beats 45%Trane: Beats 36%
  • Hot-day cooling efficiencyEER2Carrier: Beats 59%Trane: Beats 65%

Average (50%)Dashed outline: the other brand, for comparison

Want ranks, distributions per size class and cold-weather curves? Switch to Advanced

Rebate standards

Share of each brand’s models that meet the level. Programs can have other rules too.

  • CEE 2025

    Carrier
    29%
    Trane
    31%

  • Xcel CC

    Carrier
    17%
    Trane
    22%

  • CEE Advanced

    Carrier
    2%
    Trane
    0%

  • ENERGY STAR CC

    Carrier
    9%
    Trane
    10%

Top cold-climate picks, ducted up to 1.5 tons

Only units that keep at least 70% of their heat at 5°F, ranked on heat kept, efficiency at 5°F and seasonal efficiency (HSPF2), against units their size.

Showing Ducted, Up to 1.5 tons (under 21,000 Btu/h cooling). What size is my system?

Carrier

  1. 138MARBQ18AA3with ducted air handler 40MBDAQ18XH3CarrierAlso sold as Arcoaire DLCSRBH18AAK1.5 tons · 17,500 Btu/h · DuctedKeeps 95% of its heat at 5°FMeets CEE 2025, CEE 2026, Xcel CC, ENERGY STAR CC
    Heat kept at 5°F
    95% (Capacity at 5°F vs 47°F)
    Good
    Efficiency at 5°F
    2.20 (COP at 5°F)
    Great
    Seasonal efficiency
    10.8 (HSPF2)
    Top 10%
    81.3score / 100
  2. 238MARBQ09AA3with ducted air handler 40MBDQ09---3CarrierAlso sold as Arcoaire DLCSRBH09AAK1 ton · 9,000 Btu/h · DuctedKeeps 108% of its heat at 5°FMeets CEE 2025, CEE 2026, Xcel CC, ENERGY STAR CC
    Heat kept at 5°F
    108% (Capacity at 5°F vs 47°F)
    Top 10%
    Efficiency at 5°F
    1.90 (COP at 5°F)
    Below the middle
    Seasonal efficiency
    12.0 (HSPF2)
    Top 10%
    74.9score / 100
  3. 338MURAQ18AB3*with ducted air handler FM(C,U)4Z18**ALCarrierAlso sold as Airquest DLCURAH18ABK, Grandaire WDLCURAH18ABK1.5 tons · 17,800 Btu/h · DuctedKeeps 106% of its heat at 5°FMeets CEE 2025, CEE 2026, CEE Advanced, Xcel CC, DOE CCHP
    Heat kept at 5°F
    106% (Capacity at 5°F vs 47°F)
    Top 10%
    Efficiency at 5°F
    2.40 (COP at 5°F)
    Great
    Seasonal efficiency
    9.0 (HSPF2)
    Below the middle
    74.7score / 100

Trane

  1. 14A6H4018N1with ducted air handler AE(D,N,U)+CM30B34+TDRTrane (sold as American Standard)1.5 tons · 16,700 Btu/h · DuctedKeeps 88% of its heat at 5°FMeets none of the standards tracked here
    Heat kept at 5°F
    88% (Capacity at 5°F vs 47°F)
    Good
    Efficiency at 5°F
    2.83 (COP at 5°F)
    Top 10%
    Seasonal efficiency
    7.8 (HSPF2)
    Below the middle
    62.8score / 100
  2. 24TWR5018N1with indoor coil D(A,C,E)30A34+TDR and furnace *UD2B060A9V3TraneAlso sold as American Standard 4A6H5018N11.5 tons · 19,300 Btu/h · DuctedKeeps 81% of its heat at 5°FMeets Xcel CC
    Heat kept at 5°F
    81% (Capacity at 5°F vs 47°F)
    Good
    Efficiency at 5°F
    2.67 (COP at 5°F)
    Top 10%
    Seasonal efficiency
    7.8 (HSPF2)
    Below the middle
    60.6score / 100
  3. 3A4HP5018D1with ducted air handler AFM234+TDRTrane (sold as Runtru)1.5 tons · 17,300 Btu/h · DuctedKeeps 83% of its heat at 5°FMeets Xcel CC
    Heat kept at 5°F
    83% (Capacity at 5°F vs 47°F)
    Good
    Efficiency at 5°F
    2.68 (COP at 5°F)
    Top 10%
    Seasonal efficiency
    7.6 (HSPF2)
    Below the middle
    60.0score / 100

These are certified test ratings, not a recommendation for your home. The right size comes from a load calculation by a contractor.

Next steps

The advanced view adds ranks, both brands’ models inside every size class, standout models per rating and cold-weather curves.

Open the advanced view