Skip to content

Carrier vs Trane: heat pump ratings compared

Against heat pumps of the same size and type, a typical Carrier model beats 49% and a typical Trane model 50%. Trane rates slightly higher overall.

Covers heat pumps sold new today (R-454B and R-32 refrigerant). See older R-410A models · Updated

Carrier

49%

of similar heat pumps beaten by its typical model

About average

846 models listed

Trane

50%

of similar heat pumps beaten by its typical model

About average

369 models listed

Rating by ratingEach bar is the share of same-size, same-type heat pumps that a typical model beats, so the two brands compare fairly even if they make different sizes.
  • Efficiency on a 5°F dayCOP at 5°FCarrier: Beats 57%Trane: Beats 69%
  • Heating power kept at 5°FCapacity at 5°F vs 47°FCarrier: Beats 36%Trane: Beats 42%
  • Winter-long heating efficiencyHSPF2Carrier: Beats 41%Trane: Beats 35%
  • Summer-long cooling efficiencySEER2Carrier: Beats 43%Trane: Beats 40%
  • Hot-day cooling efficiencyEER2Carrier: Beats 60%Trane: Beats 67%

Average (50%)Dashed outline: the other brand, for comparison

Rebate standards

Share of each brand’s models that meet the level. Programs can have other rules too.
  • CEE 2025

    Carrier
    42%
    Trane
    39%
  • Xcel CC

    Carrier
    29%
    Trane
    25%
  • CEE Advanced

    Carrier
    1%
    Trane
    2%
  • ENERGY STAR CC

    Carrier
    27%
    Trane
    17%

Top cold-climate picks, ducted 2.5 to 3 tons

Showing Ducted, 2.5 to 3 tons (27,000 to 38,999 Btu/h cooling), the most-listed ducted size. Pick yours above. What size is my system?

Carrier

  1. 137MGHAQ36EA3Carrier (sold as Bryant)Also sold as Arcoaire D5CMHAH36EAK3 tons · 36,000 Btu/h · DuctedKeeps 106% of its heat at 5°FMeets CEE 2025, CEE 2026, Xcel CC, ENERGY STAR CC
    Heat kept at 5°F
    106% (Capacity at 5°F vs 47°F)
    Top 10%
    Efficiency at 5°F
    2.00 (COP at 5°F)
    Good
    Seasonal efficiency
    10.5 (HSPF2)
    Top 10%
    83.7score / 100
  2. 237MBHAQ36AA3with ducted air handler 45MBDAQ36XH3CarrierAlso sold as Arcoaire D5CLHAH36AAK3 tons · 36,000 Btu/h · DuctedKeeps 90% of its heat at 5°FMeets CEE 2025, CEE 2026, Xcel CC, ENERGY STAR CC
    Heat kept at 5°F
    90% (Capacity at 5°F vs 47°F)
    Good
    Efficiency at 5°F
    2.10 (COP at 5°F)
    Great
    Seasonal efficiency
    11.1 (HSPF2)
    Top 10%
    83.6score / 100
  3. 3W5HDM36K1X5ACarrier (sold as Grandaire)3 tons · 36,000 Btu/h · DuctedKeeps 106% of its heat at 5°FMeets CEE 2025, CEE 2026, Xcel CC, ENERGY STAR CC
    Heat kept at 5°F
    106% (Capacity at 5°F vs 47°F)
    Top 10%
    Efficiency at 5°F
    2.00 (COP at 5°F)
    Good
    Seasonal efficiency
    10.4 (HSPF2)
    Top 10%
    82.8score / 100

Trane

  1. 15TWV8X36A1with indoor coil D(A,C,E)36C3J+TDR and furnace S8V2C080M5PCBTrane2.5 tons · 29,800 Btu/h · DuctedKeeps 115% of its heat at 5°FMeets CEE 2025, CEE 2026, CEE Advanced, Xcel CC, DOE CCHP, ENERGY STAR CC
    Heat kept at 5°F
    115% (Capacity at 5°F vs 47°F)
    Top 10%
    Efficiency at 5°F
    2.85 (COP at 5°F)
    Top 10%
    Seasonal efficiency
    8.5 (HSPF2)
    Good
    84.6score / 100
  2. 25TWV0X36A1with indoor coil 5TEMCD05AV41+TDR and furnace N/ATraneAlso sold as American Standard 5A6V0X36A13 tons · 35,200 Btu/h · DuctedKeeps 74% of its heat at 5°FMeets CEE 2025, CEE 2026, Xcel CC, ENERGY STAR CC
    Heat kept at 5°F
    74% (Capacity at 5°F vs 47°F)
    Good
    Efficiency at 5°F
    2.20 (COP at 5°F)
    Great
    Seasonal efficiency
    10.5 (HSPF2)
    Top 10%
    80.3score / 100
  3. 35A6H7036A1with ducted air handler PL36H175P78*+TXV+TDTrane (sold as American Standard)3 tons · 33,200 Btu/h · DuctedKeeps 132% of its heat at 5°FMeets CEE 2025, CEE 2026, Xcel CC, ENERGY STAR CC
    Heat kept at 5°F
    132% (Capacity at 5°F vs 47°F)
    Top 10%
    Efficiency at 5°F
    2.28 (COP at 5°F)
    Great
    Seasonal efficiency
    8.2 (HSPF2)
    Below the middle
    79.1score / 100

These are certified test ratings, not a recommendation for your home. The right size comes from a load calculation by a contractor.

Next steps

Advanced view: ranks, both brands’ models inside every size class, the standout model on each rating, cold-weather curves.

Open the advanced view

    Send feedback

    Attached to every report

    A screenshot of this page, its address, your device and browser, recent errors and failed requests on this page, and your last clicks. Passwords and card numbers are never included. Privacy

    Ctrl or ⌘ + Enter